Catholic Business League – Connecting Catholic Business Professionals

Love at the Core: Lessons from a Grocery Store on Catholic Social Teaching

CBL Board Member Cole Crocker, CBL Board Member Margaret Smith, The Store CEO Collen Mayer, CBL Board Member Deb Varallo, CBL Board Member James Gurman, CBL Board Member Pat Lawson, CBL President Amy Sutton

What would it look like if love were the operating principle of an organization — not a slogan, but the thing that shapes the shelves and the way a neighbor is greeted at the door? That was the question we carried out of our October breakfast meeting, where we were delighted to welcome The Store CEO Collen Mayer.

Mayer has built a career of serving people in need — with United Way of Central Alabama, Catholic Charities of Tennessee, and Safe Haven Family Shelter — in addition to his role as a deacon at St. Ann Catholic Church. He now leads The Store, a free grocery store founded in March 2020 by Brad Paisley and Kimberly Williams-Paisley, where referred shoppers choose their own food. The Store is on pace to provide nearly 1 million meals this year, with 70 nonprofit partners and 3,500 volunteers. Mayer shared The Store’s work through the seven principles of Catholic social teaching, a lens that applies in any workplace.

1. Life and Dignity of the Human Person

Every person has a God-given dignity, Mayer said, and at The Store it shows up as choice. Instead of a pre-packed box, shoppers pick their own apples, the cereal their child will eat, and the vegetables their doctor recommended, just as we do each week. It is designed to remove the stigma of asking for help. One shopper put it this way: “What meant the most to me was the dignity of choice. I wasn’t judged. I was treated with respect and kindness.” Isn’t that, Mayer asked, what we all want?

2. Call to Family, Community and Participation

People flourish in relationship, and many shoppers arrive carrying isolation along with their need. A staff of just 16 or 17 is joined by thousands of volunteers who come to know shoppers by name. From the start, Mayer chose to act as a convener rather than a competitor: 70 nonprofit partners refer families back and forth, so a visit for counseling can lead to groceries and back again. Former shoppers often ask to give back, and The Store’s customer advisory group hears that again and again.

3. Rights and Responsibilities

Nutritious food, Mayer said, is a basic right, not a luxury reserved for comfortable incomes, and not everyone has access to it yet. The responsibility belongs to all of us. Whether we are in a place to give or in need of help ourselves, those with enough are called to ask how we will serve, and our faith calls us up short when neighbors lack something so basic.

4. Option for the Poor and Vulnerable

The question, Mayer said, is who is carrying the heaviest load and whether we make room for them. In January, 2,800 families were waiting to shop. A second location at TriStar Centennial Medical Center, three times the size of the first near Belmont, has helped, and Mayer is eyeing North and South Nashville. Shoppers enroll, receive a card, and shop every two weeks for about 18 months.

5. Dignity of Work and the Rights of Workers

Many shoppers are working, often in low-wage jobs, and still coming up short. Free groceries are no permanent fix, Mayer admitted, but 97 percent of shoppers say the savings help cover rent, medical bills, or a car repair. As one put it: “You either pay your bills or you buy food. Sometimes, you just can’t do both.” The Store isn’t called to do everything, he added, so it partners with groups like Goodwill, whose job-training participants can eat well while they train.

6. Solidarity

Solidarity moves us from watching a problem at a distance to joining in it. Mayer pointed to the checkout line, where a volunteer scans groceries, asks about a shopper’s day, and walks them to the car. This year, 3,500 volunteers have given 27,600 hours, and The Store could not run without them. Individual donors, corporate partners, a public grant, and the state’s Project Diabetes program fund the work, and communities across the country are calling to replicate it because, Mayer said, it simply feels right.

7. Care for God’s Creation

The traditional food box can mean waste, with unusable items ending up in the trash, even as enough food goes uneaten across the country to feed whole communities. The Store runs on wholesome donated and deeply discounted food, including surplus produce from local farmers. Creation is a gift entrusted to us, Mayer said, and rescuing good food honors both the gift and the people who receive it.

Putting Love into Action

Mayer invited us to ask how these principles show up in our own workplaces. To get involved, volunteer on your own, with family, or as a team; bring your company; invite Collen to speak to your parish or group; or come to a free monthly Lunch and Learn.

 

Thank you, Collen, for helping us see our faith at work through the aisles of a grocery store. We will be planning a day in which our CBL members can come together to lend their own time to volunteer at The Store – keep an eye on our website and social media for more details!

We look forward to seeing you all at our next two upcoming events: our CBL Happy Hour on November 4th and our next breakfast meeting on November 12th, when we’ll recognize our 2026 Catholic Professional of the Year: Thistle Farms CEO Tasha Kennard!